LGBTQIA+ FAQs
FAQs
Q. Is it fair for trans girls and women to compete in sports?
Yes. The concern about trans athletes having an unfair advantage is not supported by scientific evidence. Athletic ability varies widely and is influenced by multiple factors beyond gender identity. Studies, including a comprehensive review by the Canadian Centre for Ethics in Sport, found no basis for banning trans women from women's sports.
The real issue in women's sports is ensuring equity and access for all athletes, focusing on challenges like resource allocation and Title IX compliance. Inclusivity policies have been shown not to harm girls' sports participation. Prominent women’s sports organizations advocate for the inclusion of trans athletes, recognizing that they are not a threat to the fairness of women's sports.
Further reading:
All Your Questions About Trans Kids in Sports, Asked and Answered - Chris Mosier, Self Magazine
The Importance of Sports Participation for Transgender Youth - Center for American Progress
Q. Aren’t kids too young to make decisions about gender-affirming care?
No. This concern overlooks the rigorous, compassionate approach of gender-affirming care. Every major medical organization, including the American Medical Association and the American Association of Clinical Endocrinology, supports this care for its critical, often life-saving impact. Decisions are not made hastily; they involve thoughtful consideration and collaboration between the child, their parents, and qualified medical professionals. This care significantly improves mental health, with studies showing reduced suicidal ideation among trans youth who receive it. Delaying such essential support can have detrimental effects on the well-being of transgender youth. Gender-affirming care is a fundamental, medically endorsed aspect of healthcare for transgender individuals, providing crucial support during critical developmental stages.
Further reading:
Get the Facts on Gender-Affirming Care - HRC Foundation
AMA Strengthens Policy on Protecting Access to Gender-affirming Care - Endocrine News
Leading Medical Organization Statements - Transgender Legal & Education Fund
Q. Why should trans folks be allowed to use the bathroom that matches their gender? Isn’t it a safety concern?
A: Allowing trans folks to use bathrooms that align with their gender identity is a matter of basic human dignity and safety. There is no evidence suggesting that allowing trans individuals to use the bathroom that corresponds with their gender identity poses any safety risks. In fact, trans individuals are often the ones at risk of harassment and violence in bathrooms. Respecting bathroom rights is a crucial step in acknowledging and supporting the identity and rights of trans and gender-expansive individuals.
Further reading:
Affirming LGBTQ+ Youth Saves Lives - Lambda Legal
Q. Why should drag performances be supported when some view them as inappropriate or confusing, especially for children?
A: Drag performances, a deeply rooted tradition in the LGBTQIA+ community, are recognized as a protected artistic expression under the First Amendment. Recent legal developments affirm this: federal courts, including those appointed by Republican presidents, have blocked attempts to criminalize drag performances under state laws.
It's important to differentiate between family-friendly drag events and those for adult audiences. Recent cases in Tennessee and other states where laws targeting drag shows were blocked highlight the constitutional protection of these performances. The laws were often struck down due to their vague language and overbroad definitions, which could criminalize a wide range of artistic expressions.
Further reading:
The Lawsuits Seeking to Keep Drag Queens Legal, Explained - Vox Media
Q. Why should libraries include books with LGBTQIA+ themes, which some patrons may find controversial?
A: Banning books doesn't protect kids; it restricts their access to diverse perspectives and experiences, particularly those of the LGBTQIA+ community. Libraries should offer a wide array of educational resources, including books that reflect varied identities and lived experiences. Inclusive libraries contribute to students’ understanding and empathy, preparing them to be informed citizens in a diverse society. The current trend of book bans, often targeting LGBTQIA+ themes, undermines public education’s role in fostering a democratic, informed, and empathetic populace.
Further reading:
Q. If a child is exploring their gender identity at school, shouldn't the parents be informed?
A: Mandating schools to inform parents about a student's gender exploration raises significant concerns, primarily for the well-being of transgender students. These policies can jeopardize their privacy and safety, especially in families that may not be accepting or understanding of their gender identity.
The reality is that not all transgender youth are safe in their own homes; for many, school is the only place where they can freely and safely express their true selves. Compulsory disclosure of their gender identity can lead to increased risks of familial rejection, abuse, mental health issues, and even homelessness. And it is in opposition to the constitutional rights of students, including their right to privacy.
Further reading:
Trans Students Should Be Treated With Dignity, Not Outed by Their Schools - ACLU